Listening Test Results

Box plot from listening test.
16 participants were asked to rate 8 pages of 7 examples each (5 models, a reference and an anchor) --- 4 pages were focused on quality (timbral fidelity and absence of artefacts) and 4 pages were focused on the rejection of interference from remaining sources.

Below are random audio examples used for the listening test.

Sample 05: Vocals

Mixture (interference anchor)

Ground Truth

Demucs V4

Demucs V2

HS-TasNet

Conv-TasNet

TasNet

Anchor-Quality


Sample 54: Drums

Mixture (interference anchor)

Ground Truth

Demucs V4

Demucs V2

HS-TasNet

Conv-TasNet

TasNet

Anchor-Quality


Sample 85: Bass

Mixture (interference anchor)

Ground Truth

Demucs V4

Demucs V2

HS-TasNet

Conv-TasNet

TasNet

Anchor-Quality


Sample 34: Other

Mixture (interference anchor)

Ground Truth

Demucs V4

Demucs V2

HS-TasNet

Conv-TasNet

TasNet

Anchor-Quality


Sample 02: Vocals

Mixture (interference anchor)

Ground Truth

Demucs V4

Demucs V2

HS-TasNet

Conv-TasNet

TasNet

Anchor-Quality


Sample 39: Drums

Mixture (interference anchor)

Ground Truth

Demucs V4

Demucs V2

HS-TasNet

Conv-TasNet

TasNet

Anchor-Quality


Sample 14: Bass

Mixture (interference anchor)

Ground Truth

Demucs V4

Demucs V2

HS-TasNet

Conv-TasNet

TasNet

Anchor-Quality


Sample 53: Other

Mixture (interference anchor)

Ground Truth

Demucs V4

Demucs V2

HS-TasNet

Conv-TasNet

TasNet

Anchor-Quality